Yard Insight
Planters, Raised Beds & Greenhouses

Cold Frame vs Low Tunnel: Hoop Size and Spacing

Published · Updated

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

Cold frame vs low tunnel comes down to area and permanence. A cold frame is a small, rigid, bottomless box with a clear lid that stays where you put it for years. A low tunnel is a row of hoops with a cover stretched over it, costs the least of any season-extension structure, covers a whole bed, and comes down in an afternoon. If you have one raised bed and a short list of jobs like hardening off and overwintering, build the frame. If you want to cover everything you have before the frost arrives, hoop it.

Both are structures you buy, site and anchor, and that is what this page is about: hoop size, spacing, covering and what each one survives.

What each one is

The cold frame. University of Illinois Extension's season extension guide describes it as "essentially a bottomless box, with a clear covering." Sides are commonly wood, with Illinois noting that "wood 1-inch thick; two-inch is more costly but provides better insulative value," and that brick, concrete block, straw bales or a design sunken below grade also work. Lids are a repurposed window, greenhouse film or clear polycarbonate panel.

The build detail worth copying: Illinois recommends the covering slopes "1 inch per foot from back to front." That slope points the glazing at the low sun and sheds rain and melting snow off the front instead of ponding it in the middle of the lid.

The Royal Horticultural Society frames the cold frame's role rather than its construction. Its guidance on choosing a greenhouse calls the cold frame "a traditional means of protecting plants to supplement, not replace, a greenhouse," used for hardening off, overwintering, seed sowing and rooting cuttings. That is the honest positioning. A cold frame is a small protected box, not a building.

The low tunnel. Hoops in the ground, a cover over them, and a bed underneath. Illinois describes frames bent "into 3, 4, or 6-foot half-circle frames" from metal conduit, PVC or high-gauge wire. Width is chosen to match the bed, and height follows from width, which is why a 4-foot hoop over a standard bed is the common choice and a 6-foot hoop is for walking space rather than for plants.

Hoop spacing, and the number that keeps the tunnel standing

Hoop spacing, and the number that keeps the tunnel standing

This is where most homemade tunnels fail, and it is a hardware problem with a hardware answer.

Illinois Extension's guidance is that hoops are "spaced at a maximum of six feet apart," and adds the condition that matters in November: "Space hoops closer if you are in a high wind or area that receives lots of snow." Six feet is the ceiling, not the target.

Two more fittings from the same guidance turn a row of hoops into a structure:

  • A spine. Run "a rope along the center of the hoops to act as a spine." It stops hoops from folding sideways under load and keeps the spacing honest.
  • Ends. Put "stakes at either end" and tie the spine off to them. The ends take the wind, and an unstaked end hoop is the first one to go flat.

Wet snow, not cold, is what collapses low tunnels, because a few inches of saturated snow on a shallow curve is a surprising load across a long row. Closer hoops, a taut spine and a steeper hoop profile all help, and brushing snow off before it consolidates helps more than any of them.

Wind is the other failure mode, and the mechanism is the same one that sends patio covers across a yard: a light structure with a large surface and nothing holding its edges down. The cure is identical in both cases, which is why what works for keeping patio furniture from blowing away also works here. Bury or weight the cover edges along their full length rather than pinning them at intervals.

One material warning from Illinois that saves a cover: "PVC reacts with the greenhouse polyethylene film and quickly degrades." If your hoops are PVC, isolate them from the film with tape or cloth, or use metal conduit instead.

Cold frame vs low tunnel: the side by side

Cold frame vs low tunnel: the side by side
Cold frame Low tunnel
Area covered One small box, typically a corner of a bed A whole bed or a long row
Cost Higher per square foot, lower in total Lowest per square foot of the common options
Build time A weekend, once An hour or two, repeated each season
Lifespan Years, if the sides are durable and the lid is rigid Covers are consumable, hoops last
Wind and snow Low and heavy, so it mostly ignores both The weak point, managed with spacing, a spine and staked ends
Venting Manual, by propping the lid Depends on the cover material
Storage None. It stays put Hoops and covers come down and go away
Best at Hardening off, overwintering, cuttings, seed sowing Covering area quickly and cheaply

The duty nobody mentions: who opens it

The duty nobody mentions: who opens it

This is the practical difference that decides whether a structure helps or kills what is under it.

Illinois is direct about the frame: "Vent cold frames on warm, sunny days by propping the covering," and notes that automatic openers using compressed wax, which expands with heat, are available. A closed box in bright sun in March heats up fast, and a cold frame that nobody opens on a sunny Tuesday is a solar oven with a lid.

Low tunnels split by covering material. Spun row-cover fabric is porous and exchanges air on its own, so it does not need manual venting. Sealed polyethylene does, and a poly tunnel has to be opened at the ends or lifted along one side on bright days. Illinois recommends row cover fabric for protection "as nights begin to dip towards freezing," and greenhouse polyethylene later in the season when "temperatures continue to drop."

Choose the covering around your own schedule. If nobody is home at midday, a porous cover or a wax opener is not an upgrade, it is the thing that makes the structure work at all.

Condensation, and why these structures stay damp

Any closed structure over damp soil collects water on the inside of its coldest surface, which is the lid or the film. That is the same mechanism behind condensation in a metal or resin shed, and in a cold frame or a sealed tunnel it drips straight back onto what is underneath.

Venting on mild days is the practical control. So is the 1 inch per foot lid slope Illinois recommends, which encourages condensation to run down the inside of the glazing to the front edge rather than falling off the middle.

What neither of them is

What neither of them is

Neither structure is a frost-proof building. Illinois is explicit that a cold frame gives protection "as nights begin to dip towards freezing" but is not reliable through a typical winter in a cold state, and the RHS positions the cold frame as a supplement to a greenhouse rather than a replacement for one. Treat both as a shift of a few weeks at each end of the season and as shelter from wind and frost on marginal nights, not as a guarantee against a deep freeze.

Frequently asked questions

How far apart should low tunnel hoops be?

University of Illinois Extension gives a maximum of six feet apart, and recommends spacing them closer in areas with high wind or heavy snow. Add a rope spine along the center of the hoops and stake both ends, which is what stops hoops from folding sideways under load.

What size hoops do I need for a low tunnel?

Match the hoop width to the bed. Illinois Extension describes hoops bent into 3, 4 or 6 foot half circles from metal conduit, PVC or high-gauge wire. A 4-foot hoop suits a standard bed, while 6-foot hoops are for when you want headroom to work underneath.

Is a cold frame or a low tunnel better for winter?

A cold frame is the more durable structure and shrugs off wind and snow that would flatten a tunnel, but it covers very little ground. A low tunnel covers a whole bed for less money and needs hoops spaced closer, a spine and staked ends to survive wet snow. Many gardens end up with both.

Can I use PVC pipe for low tunnel hoops?

You can, with one caution from Illinois Extension: PVC reacts with greenhouse polyethylene film and quickly degrades it. If you use PVC, put tape or cloth between the pipe and the film at every contact point, or use metal electrical conduit bent to shape instead.

Do cold frames need to be vented?

Yes. Illinois Extension recommends venting cold frames on warm, sunny days by propping the covering, and notes that automatic openers that use compressed wax expanding with heat are available. A sealed frame in spring sun overheats quickly, which is the most common way a cold frame damages what is inside it.